沙巴、砂州難以 歸英 ,但香港可以?何解

歸英 呢種論述,除咗喺香港流行,喺大馬兩個前英國直屬殖民地州屬,主要係東馬嘅沙巴同砂磱越都相當盛行。最近又有沙巴方面講法,認為沙巴、砂磱越只係英國交俾馬來西亞托管,馬來西亞未有盡托管責任,就應歸英。

但以我對Malaysia Act 1963嘅理解,因為Malaysia Act 1963設計同Hong Kong Act 1985設計好唔同,基本上,東馬無歸英空間,只能獨立。




歸英
歸英

根據 Malaysia 1963,第一句係咁講

For the purpose of enabling North Borneo, Sarawak and Singapore (in this Act referred to as “the new States”) to federate with the existing States of the Federation of Malaya (in this Act referred to as “the Federation”), the Federation thereafter being called Malaysia, on the day on which the new States are federated as aforesaid (in this Act referred to as “the appointed day”) Her Majesty’s sovereignty and jurisdiction in respect of the new States shall be relinquished so as to vest in the manner agreed between the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the Federation and the new States.

Keyword係relinquished呢個字,即係自願放棄嘅意思。英國君主放棄咗主權同司法管轄權,已經造成國會同皇室特權上雙重棄絕嘅情況,基本上 歸英 係法理上唔可能,呢個亦係新加坡州喺1965年8月9日被踢出後,無法尋求 歸英 嘅法理原因。

而 Hong Kong 1985 第一句係咁講

As from 1st July 1997 Her Majesty shall no longer have sovereignty or jurisdiction over any part of Hong Kong.

簡單嚟講,係國會認為女皇不再有主權及司法管轄權喺香港,由於《南京條約》、《北京條約》未失效,所以一旦國會repeal Hong Kong Act 1985,香港界限街以南地區會立即回歸英國(永久割土),英國屬土公民呢個身份會立即復活等連串怪事,因為國會決議失效,皇室特權就會復活,英國喺香港主權,只係凍結狀態。

所以東馬應該儘早尋求獨立,唔好再諗 歸英 。




捐款:
Citibank Hong Kong: 14830515
恆生銀行:395-158777-882

月捐計劃





想用Google App,經呢度加入:https://goo.gl/PBroUD
捐款者可以索取八折coupon code,慳更多!

發表迴響

你的電子郵件位址並不會被公開。 必要欄位標記為 *