梁家傑勝在那裡?

陶傑剛在《壹週刊》驚訝梁家傑為何一句佳句也沒有,梁家傑就在三月一日歷史之役一戰成名,打出一場香港辯論史上的經典之役。當陶傑以為猿猴不能變成人,結果梁家傑用英式手法殺曾蔭權爵士落花流水。最諷刺的是,梁家傑在回應一名選委提問時(九千一百億那段),老人家最好唔好病,細路要生生性,查實正好援引了陶傑引用英國工黨前黨魁Neil Kinnock以下著名反戴卓爾演說。

If Margaret Thatcher is re-elected as prime minister on Thursday, I warn you. I warn you that you will have pain – when healing and relief depend upon payment. I warn you that you will have ignorance – when talents are untended and wits are wasted, when learning is a privilege and not a right. I warn you that you will have poverty – when pensions slip and benefits are whittled away by a government that won’t pay in an economy that can’t pay. I warn you that you will be cold – when fuel charges are used as a tax system that the rich don’t notice and the poor can’t afford.
I warn you that you must not expect work – when many cannot spend, more will not be able to earn. When they don’t earn, they don’t spend. When they don’t spend, work dies. I warn you not to go into the streets alone after dark or into the streets in large crowds of protest in the light. I warn you that you will be quiet – when the curfew of fear and the gibbet of unemployment make you obedient. I warn you that you will have defence of a sort – with a risk and at a price that passes all understanding. I warn you that you will be home-bound – when fares and transport bills kill leisure and lock you up. I warn you that you will borrow less – when credit, loans, mortgages and easy payments are refused to people on your melting income.

這是金諾克有名的「我警告」演說,梁家傑可以這樣妙用陶傑提供的彈藥,這就是梁大狀給陶生的英式回應。還未計那句有得揀至係老闆,完全KO掉我會做好呢份工,曾蔭權的主要金句。

曾蔭權刻意向美國總統選舉,這自不待言,這又受蔡子強《新君王論》系列書籍介紹美國打選戰手法所影響。而曾蔭權的I’ll get the job done,以至飲香港水、流香港血的言論,大這些都是學這些花招。曾蔭權,以至蔡子強,都可能以為梁家傑不懂這些招數。

但梁家傑一開首,已經用一個很動人的故事,講述他的施政願景。在回應很多問題時,他都可以用手到拿來的故事拆招,而結尾,又是另一個故事。相反,曾蔭權這次缺乏,正是故事。

梁家傑把對手想做,但做不到的事全盤學到手,就是他把曾爵士殺個片甲不留的原因。眼高手低,那是曾蔭權最大的問題。

2 thoughts on “梁家傑勝在那裡?

  1. 我無聽佢地講野,但係老曾與陳水扁一樣,都係虛無主者,佢除左口號就乜都好。以你的比較方法,老曾一定係零分。

發表迴響

你的電子郵件位址並不會被公開。 必要欄位標記為 *