為何英國人難讓BN(O)有繼承權

有時候,當你面對一個成日想做非法移民出去的國家,移民和國籍政策不緊不成。而BN(O)持有人,肯定是受害者。

http://hk.knowledge.yahoo.com/question/?qid=7007042802854

雅虎知識呢條題目認真嚇死人,用一堆中文簡體字資料答人問題那些土共,固然白痴兼白爛,但這問題亦反映出,不少中國人考慮過利用香港作跳板,移民到西方國家(但又死不融入當地社會,汗)。

所以,如果英國恢復BN(O)的英國公民身份,最大挑戰是中國的男人或女人會不會湧來搞假結婚,或者追香港男人或女人的目的,只是為了一本英籍護照。雖然現時英國對以結婚、同居或civil partnership方式取得英國公民身份,已經作出資格上的收緊,但這個問題,不得不令我們這眾爭取居英運動支持者頭痛。

一個不知自重的愚昧小農國家,永遠都令世界頭痛。

14 thoughts on “為何英國人難讓BN(O)有繼承權

  1. 呢個就係正正我最擔憂的地方, 英國怕大陸人係咁入侵
    我有諗過向 Lord GoldSmith 獻計, 就係父母都係 BN(O), 下一代先有 BC, 但我未諗清楚應該點具體去寫同埋點先唔遺返人權法等

    唔知各位有乜高見? 我地呢班 BN(O) 人,
    無理由俾呢班大陸累到我地下一代無 BN(O)

  2. 似我為例
    一家四口都有bno
    我諗我阿爸阿媽唔會因為bno有ROA而重婚卦…?
    我諗會將英籍轉給下一代只佔一小撮人…. 我daddy mammy 已經 out 左…. 最關鍵係我li類未婚人士….

  3. 但問題係, 好多香港人, 仍然係未婚的,
    況且, 結左婚的, 佢地的子女可能無 BN(O),
    咁若干年後, 佢地可能都娶大陸女人,
    而且你睇下宜家每年香港有一半男人娶大陸女人

    其實我都感到好矛盾, 既唔想大陸人有英籍,
    但我又想真正 BN(O) 人先有英籍,
    呢個係英國的最大挑戰

  4. boner:

    其實不用太擔心這個問題,現行血緣主義原則的國籍法已經可以解決,因為就算一位非英籍人士與英國公民結婚,也要在英國本土住滿3年、要考到Life in UK Test方可入籍,即是說如果這對夫婦在婚後都不打算或沒有能力在英國本土住3年,那該非英籍伴侶根本無可能入籍。

  5. 我的擔心係, 呢種心繫大陸的 BN(O) 人, 與大陸女人結婚後, 佢的下一代會因血緣而得到新的英國國籍 (可能係 BC)

    而佢地受咁親大陸的父母, 耳濡目染後, 將來可能變成好親共或做出一些對英國不利的事, 我最擔心的, 反而係呢種人, 而唔係第一代 BN(O) 的配偶

  6. I don’t think it is necessary to give citizenship to anybody who has no link with the country. BN(O)s have the status because we LIVED in colonial Hong Kong. Some has taken an oath to show allegiance to the Queen.

    I do not think it is necessary to make the BNO status transmissible. Children born in Hong Kong (SAR of China) by BN(O) parents should NOT be given BC passports, as they only have a very tenuous link with the UK. Most of them speak Cantonese, go to local schools (under the China 334 system) and probably live in China all the life. However, since BN(O)s already have ROA in the UK, it should be easy for the BNO holding parents to apply a residence visa (using the child’s HKSAR passport) for their children. The children can become a BC after fulfilling residence requirements.

    However, if BN(O)s give birth in the UK (as we can freely enter the UK), the child should be given citizenship.

    It will be too dangerous to give BN(O) the rights as a “British citizen otherwise by descent”. It will cause a deflation of BNO and BC passports and cause a national security jeopardy to the UK.

    What I propose is:
    BN(O) = British citizen by descent

  7. In worst case, the ROA enjoyed by BN(O)s need not to be transmissible. Nobody born by BN(O) parent can get a British passport. Only the BN(O) holder enjoy the right to live in the UK himself and nobody can get any benefit from a BNO holder.

    In this case, BN(O)s must go to the UK, live for 5 years, register as a full BC (otherwise by descent) and their children will enjoy the BC passport. The problems can be minimised if the BN(O)s are forced to live in the UK beforehand.

  8. 如果英國會根據英國國籍法 1971 給予 BN(O) 直接有居英權, 你地覺得有無可能爭取父母都係 BN(O) 持有人, 下一代就能得到 BC?

  9. 如果香港人取得居英權係以英國國籍法1971為依據,那就只有父親是CUKC才能繼承其英籍,但明顯地這可能構成性別歧視。

  10. 如果以1971作依據,是有可能違反歐洲人權公約,這才令後來英國修訂,可以繼續母系國籍。

  11. 咁英國仲可以根據乜去俾 BN(O) 居英權?
    因為如果以英國國籍法 1981 做籃本,
    香港人係 entitle 申請 BC, 而 BN(O) 繼續無居英權,
    唔知世澤兄點睇?

  12. Bnoer提的,正係BOTC模式。修改點唔係British Nationality Act,而係Hong Kong Act,亦即BN(O)的法源。

  13. 但我真係好希望 BN(O) 人可以在非英國定居的方式下, 能將英籍傳俾下一代

    我一路都希望建議, 如果父母同時有 BN(O), 有無可能爭取下一代都有 BC 或類似 BN(O) 物體?

發表迴響

你的電子郵件位址並不會被公開。 必要欄位標記為 *